My audience feedback was very positive. I selected people from my age range who immediately knew what the story was behind the music video. They also gave me positive feedback to the black and while theme. They thought the editing worked, and the fact that I used only one actor worked well.
I also decided to do a small questionnaire, the questionnaire just had 6 questions in it and it was open for discussion as well as closed questions. I managed to get responses from 22 people. These 22 people were from my target audience and 9 of which were female and 13 were male. I showed them my music video one by one and allowed them to go back to bits or watch it as many times as they wanted.
The questions that I asked were:
On a scale of 1-10 what would you rate my music video as?
What do you think of the whole black and white theme?
What do you think of the idea of using just one actor?
Should I have tried to change my location?
Did you understand that the bits in colour were actual time and the black and white theme was past?
What are the best and worst bits about this music video?
For the first question 18 out of the 22 people I asked gave me 8 out of 10. They also said in conversation they like the way the video speeds up when the music speeds up.
One of my responses was only a 5 as they said it didn't quite fit the genre of music and another response was an 11. I was very happy with this result as 8 out of 10 is a high score for my first ever time at creating a music video.
For the second question it was open for discussion I left the space on my questionnaire for people to add their own feedback. Unfortunately for the second question I pretty much only got one word answers or short sentences. I had 5 people just write good, 8 people just saying they like it and the rest just putting very good or it worked well. I should of perhaps broke that question down to get the best possible feedback I could of got.
For the next question 20 out of the 22 people I asked all said I should have used more than one actor just for the guitar and instruments. When I asked them to expand on it they said that the idea of one actor is good however in a rock music video (soft and heavy metal) they use several people. The other two people said they enjoyed the one actor being the only person in the video as it didn't confuse them. This feedback made me realise I should of been more organised and had more actors on standby and a back up plan. I think if I had the chance I would add different people into the video.
The next question about changing my location I already new that I should of tried to however I asked this question just to work out whether it did wreck my video or not. 13 of the people I asked said yes I should of perhaps thought to film in different locations. 4 of them 13 said that even in my garden or in a different room would of broke it down slightly. 9 of the people I asked said no to that question when speaking to one of the person after the questionnaire she said that she believes that the video is about memory and present and if so why should I change the location if its about memories. I do take this criticism on board and realise that it could of made a big difference if I did change location but at the time I thought the shots were enough and I enjoyed what I did film.
I felt with the next question I should of rephrased it, I had to explain to the audience what it meant. Basically I wanted to know if people understood the reason why I put colour into this video even though its mainly black and white. All of my responses were yes we did know it was to symbolise past and present. I was happy with that because that is what I wanted my audience to realise when watching this video.
The last question I asked about the best and worst bits again got one word responses and short sentences. 6 out of the 22 people said the best part of the video is the way I edited it. 1 person said the best part was the way I ended the video by him walking out of the door. 10 people said they liked the black and white theme, and the rest just said it was good, or it all flowed. For the worst bits 1 person did say that the syncing was slightly out at parts and 10 people said that when my actor was miming the retro style was a bit too much. The rest of the people just made comments about it slightly jumping in places and that I should have used more actors.
Overall I am very happy with the feedback I got and if I had another chance I would definitely take it on board and create an even better video.
Finally for my audience feedback I also posted it on facebook and looked at what responses I received for that.
Unfortunately I didn't much constructive feedback apart from it was good or I should be proud however I was still happy with the feedback I got.
I have learned that with all this feedback I perhaps need to consider my change of location and actors within my music video apart from that I am very happy with what I produced.